data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4f077/4f0778827e87f22c3daf24b6501a6dd875b10ffe" alt=""
Hey there! On a message board last night, a poster posed the following questions about crafts and feminism as part of her dissertation research, and I found the answers really interesting, so I've asked her permission to pinch her questions to pose to you! I thought it'd be interesting to hear everyone's thoughts since a lot of you are crafters yourselves - I'll feed any answers back to her to help with her research if that's alright! My answers are below, too!
I'm writing my dissertation on the rise of knitting/crafts and how it fits in with third wave feminist analysis' of women's interests and hobbies and lifestyle choices. I'm doing some research into why women like knitting [and other crafts] and why they started doing it, so would anyone mind answering a few questions for me? I'm hoping to carry out real life interviews and I think it would be good to get a few responses to shape the questions I ask!
1) How did you learn to knit? Were you taught by a family member or friend?
2) Do you attend any knitting groups, such as stitch 'n bitch? If so, why?
3) Why did you decide to take up knitting?
4) What do you enjoy about it, what do you get out of it?
5) What image do you think knitting has? Do you think there is still an association with old ladies or has this changed?
6) Do you think knitting and crafts get the same attention as other arts? Do you think they should be worthy of the same interest?
7) Knitting has traditionally been defined as women's work, as something domestic which holds us back from equality. If this is true, why are so many young women engaging in it?
----------------------------------------
I can't knit yet, but I've recently taught myself to crochet, so these are about crochet if that's alright!
1) I've been trying to learn to both knit and crochet for years, and everybody (mum, grandma, many family friends!) who's ever attempted to teach me has almost murdered me in frustration ha so I subscribed to a 'learn to crochet' magazine recently and learned that way!
2) I don't attend any groups, but we do have friends who like to get together and knit so I might start joining them, because it does get a bit lonely crocheting on my own in front of the TV!
3) I wanted to be able to make things like my mum and grandma do - we have so many lovely things around the house that are homemade, and they've lasted for years and years and I wanted to be able to make things like that, perhaps for my children...and also to pass some time creatively because my job is only part-time!
4) I enjoy how quickly you can create something...although I'd like to be quicker! It's really satisfying and something to chat about!
5) When I was younger it definitely had an association with older people, but my mum has always knitted and crocheted since being a teenager, so the idea grew on me as I got older, and now I know so many people who knit socially, I think the image has reversed and it's a bit cool now!
6) No I don't think they get the same recognition, unless there's something really very different about what's been made. I'm not sure whether they should have as much recognition...I guess I think they should have more within fashion and textiles rather than art. A lot of what is created when you knit, certainly as a beginner, is done from a pattern, so arguably more repetitive and less creative than other arts, but I think really spectacular creations are getting more and more recognition, especially with the increase in fashion and craft blogs and information being shared so easily.
7) I think nowadays it's easier for young women (in the context of young British women taking up knitting and crafts) to do exactly what they want to do with much less fear of being judged than perhaps twenty/thirty years ago when a lot of feminist activity was focused on equality, and to be equal, women had to shake off traditional views of themselves. Nowadays, if women want to do something traditionally seen as masculine (engineering, armed forces, go into business etc), they are for the most part positively encouraged, so it gives the freedom to do exactly what you want to do without fear of being seen as either masculine or feminine whether it be flying a plane, building a train engine, making cards (my boyfriend will be delighted I'm sharing that he does ha!), knit a scarf or be a doctor. I really don't know enough about it to discuss it particularly intelligently, it just feels that way to me!
I'd love to hear all your thoughts!data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a39e3/a39e390cabafe4c2cce664f45ec330c6632ff2e2" alt=""
In other news, the tiny bit of crochet at the top of the post was the beginning of my boyfriend's cushion (which I began rambling about in
this post!) and I've since decided that the wool, despite being beautiful, is far more suited to a baby than to a 24-year-old boy and it's also so fine that the four rows above took me the best part of two hours...I should probably have realised this sooner, but now I have two balls of wool and no babies to crochet anything for haha so has anybody got any ideas? I also need to buy some more manly wool for this...I guess practise makes perfect, though!